fable/data/fallacy/informal/tu_quoque.json

{
    "unit": {
        "Fallacy": {
            "InformalFallacy": "TuQuoque"
        }
    },
    "title": "Galactic Logic Academy: Deflecting the Tu Quoque Trap",
    "screens": [
        {
            "screen_type": "Text",
            "text": "Welcome back, Cadet! The galaxy faces a new challenge: leaders are deflecting valid criticisms by pointing out the flaws of others. This tactic, known as the tu quoque fallacy, undermines reasoned debate. Your mission is to identify and counter this fallacy to restore productive dialogue. Ready to take on the challenge? Let's begin!",
            "question": null,
            "options": null,
            "correct_indices": null,
            "correct_text": null,
            "hints": null
        },
        {
            "screen_type": "Text",
            "text": "The tu quoque fallacy, also known as the 'you too' fallacy, occurs when someone responds to criticism by accusing their critic of the same or similar behavior, rather than addressing the argument itself. This deflection distracts from the issue at hand and prevents meaningful resolution.",
            "question": null,
            "options": null,
            "correct_indices": null,
            "correct_text": null,
            "hints": null
        },
        {
            "screen_type": "Text",
            "text": "For example, imagine a planetary leader being criticized for polluting their planet. Instead of addressing the criticism, they respond, 'Well, your planet pollutes too!' This response does not justify their actions or address the original concern.",
            "question": null,
            "options": null,
            "correct_indices": null,
            "correct_text": null,
            "hints": null
        },
        {
            "screen_type": "Mcq",
            "text": "",
            "question": "Which of the following is an example of the tu quoque fallacy?",
            "options": [
                "A leader responds to criticism about corruption by saying, 'You're corrupt too!'",
                "A leader explains their actions by providing evidence and reasoning.",
                "A leader acknowledges the criticism and promises to improve."
            ],
            "correct_indices": [0],
            "correct_text": null,
            "hints": [
                "Look for responses that deflect criticism by accusing the critic of similar behavior."
            ]
        },
        {
            "screen_type": "Text",
            "text": "The tu quoque fallacy is problematic because it shifts the focus away from the original argument. Even if the critic is guilty of similar behavior, it does not invalidate their criticism or justify the actions being criticized.",
            "question": null,
            "options": null,
            "correct_indices": null,
            "correct_text": null,
            "hints": null
        },
        {
            "screen_type": "Checkboxes",
            "text": "",
            "question": "Which of the following are examples of the tu quoque fallacy? Select all that apply.",
            "options": [
                "A planetary leader responds to criticism about their environmental policies by saying, 'Your planet has environmental issues too!'",
                "A leader accused of dishonesty replies, 'Well, you've lied before!'",
                "A leader criticized for high taxes responds, 'Other planets have higher taxes!'",
                "A leader accused of unfair trade practices says, 'Your planet's trade practices are worse!'",
                "A leader responds to criticism by providing evidence that their policies are effective."
            ],
            "correct_indices": [0, 1, 2, 3],
            "correct_text": null,
            "hints": [
                "Focus on responses that deflect criticism by pointing out flaws in the critic."
            ]
        },
        {
            "screen_type": "Text",
            "text": "To counter the tu quoque fallacy, focus on the original argument. Acknowledge any valid points made by the critic, but avoid deflecting by pointing out their flaws. This approach fosters constructive dialogue and helps resolve disputes.",
            "question": null,
            "options": null,
            "correct_indices": null,
            "correct_text": null,
            "hints": null
        },
        {
            "screen_type": "Mcq",
            "text": "",
            "question": "How can you effectively counter the tu quoque fallacy?",
            "options": [
                "Focus on the original argument and avoid deflecting.",
                "Respond by pointing out the critic's flaws.",
                "Ignore the criticism entirely."
            ],
            "correct_indices": [0],
            "correct_text": null,
            "hints": [
                "The goal is to address the argument, not deflect or ignore it."
            ]
        },
        {
            "screen_type": "Text",
            "text": "Congratulations, Cadet! You've successfully completed the Galactic Logic Academy's unit on the tu quoque fallacy. By identifying and countering this fallacy, you are helping to promote reasoned debate and restore harmony across the galaxy. The stars shine brighter because of your efforts!",
            "question": null,
            "options": null,
            "correct_indices": null,
            "correct_text": null,
            "hints": null
        }
    ]
}